Rooted Rising Logo
Stories for Action
Rethinking the Host Community Development Trust

Rethinking the Host Community Development Trust

HomeBlogsRethinking the Host Community Development Trust
R

Published by

Rooted Rising

Date

October 10, 2026

Story

Rethinking the Host Community Development Trust

(HCDT)

For communities hosting oil companies or operations in Nigeria, development is often presented as something you can see. A new road, a school, a health centre, a borehole, a town hall etc. These interventions matter where public infrastructure has long been inadequate. A borehole can provide drinking water where the river is polluted. But it cannot bring the river itself back to life, nor the livelihoods such as fisher folks hat depended on it.

HCDTs are for the financing of projects such as: schools, hospitals, boreholes, town halls etc. These matters, but the portfolio so far is dominated by physical infrastructure, with little focus on restoration, remediation or environmental justice, the very issues that underpin livelihoods in host communities.

Who Defines Need and Who Holds Power?

The oil companies also known as Settlors play a significant role in conducting the needs assessment that informs the Community Development process and in shaping the Board of Trustees.

If the party responsible for petroleum operations also frames that assessment and shapes the governance structure for community funds, communities end up just saying “yes or no”, instead of choosing what they really want. Thereby choosing from pre-determined options rather than setting the agenda themselves.

Trustees are drawn from host communities, but a seat at the table has limited value if it does not carry real influence. A credible process must allow women, youth, persons with disabilities, fisher folks, farmers and other often-overlooked groups not just to be consulted, but to deliberate, question expenditures and insist on projects that reflect their realities.

Is 3% Enough?

The 3% of actual annual operating expenditure (OPEX), creates a mandatory funding stream. Yet many host communities carry challenges accumulated over decades, degraded environments, lost livelihoods, health concerns, infrastructure deficits etc.

The question is not just whether 3% is too small, but whether this 3% can really fix the many problems that have piled up over many years. More funding does not automatically mean better outcomes, just as legal compliance does not guarantee that real needs of the people would be met.

Even the 3% is not secured as Section 257 from the PIA provides for forfeiture of a community's entitlement to the extent of repair costs where vandalism, sabotage or civil unrest damages petroleum facilities.

A community is not a single individual. A teacher, farmer, trader or elderly resident may have no connection to an incident, yet bear the loss of development funds. When one person causes the problem (and that person may not even be from the community), but the whole community is punished for it, fairness becomes difficult to defend.

Can Infrastructure Fix a Dead River?

A road can connect people, a school can educate them, a borehole can give them water to drink, but it doesn’t restore a polluted river, a health center can save lives, but when our lands are barren and our rivers are polluted from oil activities, how will those same lives feed themselves? What will they eat? None of these rehabilitates degraded farmland, or replaces a livelihood lost through environmental damage.

Constructing a borehole may be necessary, but it cannot be treated as an equivalent response to ecological destruction. It is a palliative, not restoration.

This matters because environmental protection is among the objectives of the HCDT framework. The question is how strongly restoration features when communities prioritise projects. If success is measured mainly by the number of structures delivered, a community can appear to be progressing while the ecological foundation of its economy continues to deteriorate.

Who takes accountability?

Another important question is whether institutional accountability becomes community accessible accountability; can the people in charge answer to the community? For example can an ordinary resident answer: How much entered our Trust? What was approved? What was budgeted? What is completed? Where do I complain and what happens after?

Transparency is not only the publication of information; it is the creation of conditions where affected people can understand, challenge and participate in decisions concerning resources meant for them.

What Community Development should be

The HCDT will achieve its promise only if development is understood as more than project delivery. This needs real community participation, real power to decide, projects that focus on restoring our environment, and leaders who actually answer to us.

An HCDT should not be judged by how many buildings it puts up, but by whether our community has more power, a healthier environment, better livelihoods, and a way to hold leaders accountable.

Infrastructure is not development, when the river is dead and the ecosystem is ruined.

By Mirabel Adaeze Longep

Project Lead, Environmental Justice

Rooted Rising Initiative

Discussion & Reviews

1

Overall Rating

Posting as Anonymous

P
Perfect
10/10/2026

Great post